Monday, January 06, 2014

Adoption Movies

Any idea what the following legendary individuals have in common?
  • Moses
  • Jesus
  • Superman
  • Kung Fu Panda
You got it. They were adopted.

I think it is important for children to see themselves in our world -- to not feel alone. We often remind Isaac that he is adopted just like some of these legendary characters listed above.

I recently stumbled upon a selection of good "adoption-movie-conversation-starters." I wanted to share this list with you. Please note that I have not seen all of these movies. I hope to have my own opinion on these in the future.

            RATED G            
Meet the Robinsons -- HAVE NOT SEEN THIS ONE YET
Twelve-year-old Lewis lives in an orphanage. He loves to invent things, and never gives up on his ideas (one invention took more than 900 tries). He's had 124 interviews with prospective parents, though, and is ready to give up on the hope of being adopted. With the help of a mysterious stranger, Lewis travels 20 years into the future and meets the loving family that will be his. He returns to the present time with his hope renewed. This is a cute, kid-friendly movie. Some aspects may be troubling, but it's altogether positive, and raises good discussion points.

The adoption interview scenes and the sense of "auditioning" for prospective parents might not sit well with some kids (or some parents). On the other hand, Mildred, the orphanage director, is loving and positive—a rarity in movie portrayals! Before one interview, she tells Lewis, "Go show them how special you are."

Discussion Questions for Meet the Robinsons
  • Have you kept working on something when you wanted to give up? How did it turn out?
  • When has it been hard to keep hoping for something?
  • Which people were the kindest to you, before you came to live with me/us?

The Tigger Movie -- SEEN IT! LOVE IT!
"The wonderful thing about Tiggers / Is Tiggers are wonderful things.... They're bouncy, trouncy, flouncy, pouncy / Fun, fun, fun, fun, fun! / But the most wonderful thing about Tiggers / Is I'm the only one!" sings Tigger, but he begins to wonder why he's the only one. Where are all the other tiggers? In a misguided effort to help, his friends write a letter that purports to be from his birth family. When Tigger discovers that they wrote it, he heads out in a blizzard to look for other tiggers. His friends go after him, and he eventually realizes that they are his family. The question of where the other tiggers are (or whether there are other tiggers) is not resolved. This will mirror the experience of some adoptees: answers are not always available.

Roo and his mother, Kanga, have a wonderful conversation. Roo says that he wishes Tigger were part of his family. Kanga responds, "He already is and always will be." Roo continues, "I still wish I could do something to make him feel better." While Roo understands that his mother views Tigger as part of their family, he also realizes that this does not make Tigger feel better. We can all follow Roo's example—offer unconditional love, acceptance, and inclusion, but do not expect that your offerings will immediately or completely fill the void an adoptee is feeling.

This brief, sweet film encourages the idea of finding happiness with the people you know and love, but doesn't ignore the desire to learn about your first family. Older adoptees who have younger siblings might be convinced to watch The Tigger Movie as a family, and would likely benefit from it.

Discussion Questions for The Tigger Movie
  • Tigger spent a lot of time imagining what other tiggers would be like. What do you imagine your birth family is like?
  • What could Tigger's friends have done to help him feel better instead of pretending to be his birth family and writing the letter?
  • Roo always wanted to be Tigger's friend and didn't want him to feel alone. Who are your good friends? 
            RATED PG            
Despicable Me and Despicable Me 2 -- SEEN BOTH OF THESE AND LOVE THEM BOTH!
Both of these animated features got a lot of hype. The first one portrayed adoption poorly; the sequel handled it very well.

In Despicable Me, the villain Gru adopts Margo, Edith, and Agnes from Miss Hattie's orphanage. The orphanage was a miserable place, where punishments included sitting in a "box of shame," but the girls' life with Gru is no better—he adopts them only because he needs them for his evil plan. Toward the end of the movie, he returns them to the orphanage, then has a change of heart and goes back to re-claim them.

Discussion Questions for Despicable Me
  • Gru was not someone the girls could depend on. How did they know whether he was trustworthy later?
  • Is Miss Hattie's orphanage like any place you've lived?
In the second movie, we see a completely different Gru. He's now working with the Anti-Villain League. More important, he's become less selfish, more involved with his children's lives, and is doing his best to be a good single dad. When his oldest daughter starts to date, Gru is particularly overprotective, which may ring true for some adoptive parents.

Discussion Questions for Despicable Me 2
  • What makes Gru a good dad?
  • When Agnes reveals that she's sad because she doesn't have a mom, Gru's response is a little insensitive. What should he have said?

Kung Fu Panda and Kung Fu Panda 2 -- A REAL FAVORITE IN OUR HOUSE!
These fun movies will definitely appeal to kids, and both handle adoption well. Po, a Kung Fu-loving panda bear, was adopted and raised by Mr. Ping, a goose who owns a noodle shop. Po is conflicted, feeling that he must choose between his own passion and his family's calling, but, with his father's encouragement, learns to incorporate both into his identity. By the end of Kung Fu Panda, Mr. Ping has given his son the secret family recipe, and Po has become a great noodle cook, as well as a Dragon Warrior.

Discussion Questions for Kung Fu Panda
  • Po has a hard time telling his dad what he wants to be. What do you wish you could tell your parents?
  • In the beginning, Po is dreaming of fitting in with the Furious Five. What do you dream of?
  • How are you like your mom and dad? How are you like your birthparents?
Although it was implied in the first film, it's only in Kung Fu Panda 2 that Mr. Ping tells his son that he was adopted. They have an honest conversation, though Mr. Ping isn't able to satisfy all of Po's curiosity about who he is. Po recalls traumas from his early childhood, and he fears his birthparents didn't love him. A soothsayer reassures him that they did, and also counsels, "Your story might not have a happy beginning, but it's who you choose to be that makes you who you are."

Discussion Questions for Kung Fu Panda 2
  • How much of your story do you remember? What have you been told?
  • Which parts of your story do you not know? What do you imagine about the parts you don't know? What do you hope is true?

Elf -- SEEN IT! LOVE IT!
This Will Ferrell comedy gets a lot of play around Christmas time. It's, of course, meant to be light-hearted, but some scenes may evoke painful emotions.

A baby at an orphanage crawls into Santa's sack and ends up at the North Pole, where he's named Buddy and raised by Papa Elf. Buddy doesn't fit in, due to his size, but is told only as an adult that he was adopted. He sets off to New York City to find his birthfather, Walter—and is harshly rejected by this man who's on Santa's "naughty list." For most of the movie, Buddy doesn't feel like he belongs in either world. Finally, Buddy is accepted by his birthfather.

Discussion Questions for Elf
  • Is Buddy an elf, a human, both, or something else?
  • Walter eventually apologizes for what he said to Buddy ("I don't care that you're my son. Get out of my life, now!"). Is the apology enough to clear Walter of wrongdoing? To heal Buddy's hurt feelings?

Martian Child -- ON MY LIST TO WATCH!
David Gordon, a widower, is adopting from foster care. He's matched with an eccentric six-year-old named Dennis, who claims he's from Mars. Martian Child offers an honest portrayal of David's questioning, wondering whether he is qualified to be a parent, and of the rocky adjustment period. Dennis steals some of David's belongings, including pictures of his wife. When David finds out, Dennis asks, "Was I bad? You're going to send me away because I took your stuff?" David responds, "There's nothing you could do that would change the way I feel. I'm not going to ever send you away." One of the best cinematic depictions of foster care I've seen!

Discussion Questions for Martian Child
  • Have you ever felt abandoned, as Dennis did?
  • What was the most important thing that David told Dennis?

            RATED PG-13            
Man of Steel -- HAVE NOT SEEN THIS YET!
Yes, Superman was adopted! When Jor-El and Lara learn that their planet, Krypton, will soon explode, they send their newborn, Kal-El, to Earth. As they say goodbye, Lara mourns because she will "never get to see him walk or hear him say our names." The baby is found by Jonathan and Martha Kent, who adopt him and name him Clark.

This film is best for preteens and teens. It offers a nuanced view of identity, even though it seems to encourage a degree of secrecy around adoption—and is also quite violent. Jonathan struggles to be honest about Clark's adoption. After he reveals the truth, there's a painful confrontation when Clark says, in classic adolescent-adoptee fashion, "You're not my dad, just some guy who found me." His dad's response truly made me cringe: "You're right. We're not your parents. We're just doing as best we can." Ultimately, Jonathan avows that he is Clark's father, and that Clark must explore his heritage. Clark understands that he can be a "child of Earth" as well as a child of Krypton.

Discussion Questions for Man of Steel
  • Superman gets to meet his birthfather. What do you wish you could ask your birthparents? (Or, in an open adoption, What do you talk about with your birthparents?)
  • Have you ever felt like you had to hide a secret from everyone?
  • Superman struggles to integrate his Kryptonian heritage with his earthling identity. How do you identify with your birth culture? With our family's culture? 
Moonrise Kingdom -- HAVE NOT SEEN THIS YET!
Sam, an orphan, is at scout camp when his foster family informs the camp that they won't take him back at the end of the summer. Suzy is the daughter of two belligerent lawyers, and acts out. These two 12-year-olds have been pen pals for the past year, and neither has any other friends. They decide to run away—he from camp, she from her home, and both are running from loneliness. During the search for Sam and Suzy (and an ensuing escapade when the other scouts start feeling guilty about ostracizing Sam and work to prevent his being sent to a "juvenile refuge"), the local police captain becomes Sam's mentor, and eventually his new foster father
.
Several of the scouts, and even Suzy, say some pretty insensitive things. In one scene, Suzy tells Sam, "I wish I was an orphan. Almost all of my favorite characters are. It seems like your lives are more special." (Seems like a prime example of something you should never say to an adoptee.) Sam responds, "I love you, but you don't know what you're talking about."

Discussion Questions for Moonrise Kingdom
  • Have you ever thought that your life story was talked about by lots of people? How did you feel about that?
  • Have you ever wanted to tell someone, "I love you, but you don't know what you're talking about"?

2 comments:

betsy trogden said...

Meet the Robinsons is one of our favorite movies!! Absolutely LOVE it. And the story...wonderful!!

Anonymous said...

I love, love, LOVE Meet the Robinsons. I cry at the end every single time I watch it. This movie is unique in that it deals with adoption of an older child (although, so does Despicable Me). It's also funny and a little nerdy, but has a wonderful message for both parents and children.

Bethany